Supreme Court Of Canada | Case Nos. 41516 and 41644

Nov 19, 2026

Aboriginal Title & Overlapping Claims

What is the Supreme Court of Canada? 

The Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) is Canada’s highest court. It makes final decisions on important legal questions, including constitutional rights, Indigenous rights and the interpretation of Canadian laws. 

The Court has nine judges, including one Chief Justice and eight other justices. They are appointed by the Governor General on the advice of the Prime Minister. 

Unlike a trial court, the Supreme Court generally does not hear witnesses or examine new evidence. Instead, it reviews decisions made by lower courts to determine whether the law was correctly interpreted and applied. 

During a hearing, lawyers for the parties present their legal arguments to the justices, who can interrupt at any time to ask questions, challenge arguments or explore different interpretations of the law. 

These exchanges are an important part of the process. The justices may ask difficult questions, test hypothetical situations or raise concerns about how a decision could affect future cases. 

Importantly, the questions justices ask do not necessarily reveal how they will rule. They are exploring the legal issues from different perspectives before reaching a decision. 

SCC decisions are final and set legal precedents that other courts across Canada must follow.

Why does this matter for Gitanyow?

On December 8 and 9, 2025, the SCC heard appeals concerning whether the Nisga’a Nation and Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation (TSKLH) should be allowed to participate as defendants in Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title case, Malii v. The King. TSKLH is also seeking to advance its own Aboriginal Title claim within Gitanyow’s case. 

There are different levels of participation in court proceedings. A defendant is a full party to the lawsuit, with extensive rights to present evidence, question witnesses and make legal arguments. An intervener generally has a more limited role, providing legal arguments on specific issues with the Court’s permission. 

Lawyers representing the parties, including Canada and British Columbia (B.C.), presented their arguments, along with lawyers representing interveners. Interveners are Indigenous Nations, organizations or other groups granted permission by the Court to offer additional legal perspectives on issues that could have broader implications beyond this case. 

The Supreme Court is not deciding whether Gitanyow holds Aboriginal Title to the Lax’yip. Instead, it is considering important legal questions about who can participate in Aboriginal Title cases, under what circumstances and what legal tests should apply. 

The Court’s decision could have significant implications for Indigenous Nations across Canada pursuing recognition of their Aboriginal Title, particularly those with overlapping territorial claims or where one or more Nations hold rights under historic or modern treaties.

Gitanyow’s Lower Court Decisions 

January 17, 2024 – B.C. Supreme Court
The B.C. Supreme Court ruled in Gitanyow’s favour, rejecting the Nisga’a Nation’s application to join Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title case as a defendant. 

August 7, 2024 – B.C. Supreme Court
In a separate decision, the B.C. Supreme Court allowed TSKLH to join Gitanyow’s Title case as a defendant and advance its own Aboriginal Title claim within the same proceedings.  

Gitanyow appealed. 

August 29, 2024 – B.C. Court of Appeal
The Nisga’a Nation appealed the January decision, but all three judges at the B.C. Court of Appeal unanimously upheld the lower court ruling, marking a second legal victory for Gitanyow in its dispute with the Nisga’a Nation. 

December 5, 2024 – B.C. Court of Appeal
The Court of Appeal partially ruled in Gitanyow’s favour, allowing TSKLH to remain a defendant but overturning the decision that would have permitted TSKLH to advance its own Aboriginal Title claim within Gitanyow’s case.

April 24, 2025 – Supreme Court of Canada
The SCC agreed to hear the appeals involving the Nisga’a Nation and TSKLH, including Gitanyow’s challenge to TSKLH’s participation as a defendant.

What Questions Must the Supreme Court Consider?

1. Access to justice:
How should courts balance Gitanyow’s right to pursue recognition of its Aboriginal Title without unnecessary delays against the rights of other Indigenous Nations seeking to participate?

Access to justice was an important consideration in the lower courts because Aboriginal Title cases are already extremely expensive, complicated, and time-consuming. Adding more parties can introduce new evidence, legal arguments and delays, making it even harder for Indigenous Nations to have their claims heard.

The lower courts recognized that Gitanyow has spent many years pursuing recognition of its Aboriginal Title, and that unnecessary delays could undermine its access to justice.

However, courts must also consider whether excluding other Indigenous Nations from the proceedings could unfairly affect their rights protected under Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982.

A key concern is the legal principle of res judicata, which generally prevents matters already decided by a court from being relitigated. The question is whether a final ruling could have lasting legal consequences for Nations that were not permitted to participate, potentially limiting their ability to protect or assert their rights in future proceedings.

During the Supreme Court hearings, lawyers highlighted just how lengthy Aboriginal Title trials can be. The Delgamuukw and Tsilhqot’in trials lasted more than 300 days in court, while the Cowichan Title trial lasted more than 500 court days over four years.

Lawyers also raised concerns when several Indigenous Nations claim overlapping territory; allowing every Nation to join the same lawsuit could result in numerous parties presenting evidence, questioning witnesses and making legal arguments. This could significantly prolong proceedings and increase legal costs.

2. Nisga’a Treaty rights:
Does the Nisga’a Nation’s modern treaty give it the right to join Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title case as a full defendant?

Being a full defendant would allow the Nisga’a Nation to participate directly in the court proceedings, including presenting evidence, questioning witnesses and making legal arguments.

The Nisga’a Nation argues that it must be allowed to participate as a defendant to protect its constitutionally recognized treaty rights, particularly where Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title claim overlaps lands covered by the Nisga’a Treaty.

However, the lower courts ruled that Gitanyow is seeking recognition of its Aboriginal Title against the Crown, not against the Nisga’a Nation. Gitanyow structured its case to first seek a declaration of Aboriginal Title, with questions about specific rights and damages to be addressed later. The courts found that recognizing Gitanyow’s Title at this stage would not, by itself, remove Nisga’a’s existing treaty rights or trigger the treaty provisions requiring Nisga’a’s participation as a defendant.

The Nisga’a Treaty also contains provisions for addressing situations where another Indigenous Nation establishes rights in overlapping territory.

The Supreme Court must now consider whether the Nisga’a Treaty gives Nisga’a the right to participate in Gitanyow’s case or whether a judge must first determine if its participation is necessary and fair to everyone involved.

3. TSKLH’s standing and participation:
What must TSKLH establish to participate as a defendant in Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title case?

Should courts first examine whether TSKLH is an Aboriginal rights-holding collective, whether its representatives have the authority to act on its behalf and whether its overlapping territorial claim has a sufficient factual basis?

4. TSKLH’s Aboriginal Title claim:
Should TSKLH be allowed to pursue its own Aboriginal Title claim against Canada and B.C. within Gitanyow’s existing lawsuit?

TSKLH already filed a separate Aboriginal Title lawsuit in April 2024. However, it also wants to pursue its claim within Gitanyow’s case, arguing that the overlapping territorial claims should be considered together.

The B.C. Court of Appeal rejected this request, finding that adding a second Aboriginal Title claim would significantly increase the cost, complexity and length of Gitanyow’s proceedings.

The Supreme Court must now consider whether allowing TSKLH to pursue its claim within Gitanyow’s lawsuit is necessary and fair, or whether its separate lawsuit provides a more appropriate path.

5. Overlapping Aboriginal Title claims:
Can a court recognize one Indigenous Nation’s Aboriginal Title without affecting the rights of other Indigenous Nations claiming the same territory? Or must competing claims be heard together?

This was an important question explored by the justices and lawyers during the Supreme Court hearings.

Gitanyow is seeking recognition of its Aboriginal Title against the Crown (Canada and B.C.), not against other Indigenous Nations. Gitanyow argues that the courts can recognize its Title “without prejudice” to the rights of other Indigenous Nations that may also claim the territory. This means recognizing Gitanyow’s Title without deciding or limiting the rights of those other Nations. Gitanyow’s position is that other Nations can pursue their own claims without those claims having to be determined within Gitanyow’s existing case.

However, other parties argue that because Aboriginal Title includes the right to exclusive use and occupation of land, recognizing one Nation’s Title could affect the rights of others claiming the same territory.

The justices also raised questions about whether Indigenous Nations with overlapping territorial claims could resolve their differences through negotiations, rather than relying on the courts to settle disputes.

The Supreme Court must consider whether a declaration of Aboriginal Title can be made without prejudicing the rights of other Indigenous Nations, or whether overlapping claims must be addressed within the same court proceedings.

6. Legal tests for future Aboriginal Title cases:
What rules should courts follow when another Indigenous Nation wants to join an existing Aboriginal Title lawsuit?

During the Supreme Court hearings, the justices explored whether clearer legal tests are needed to determine who should be allowed to participate in Aboriginal Title cases and what evidence should be required before another party can join.

An important question was whether courts should first examine a group’s legal standing, including whether it represents an Indigenous rights-holding collective, whether its representatives have the authority to act on its behalf and whether there is sufficient evidence to support its claim to overlapping territory.

The justices also questioned whether these matters should be examined before a group is allowed to participate or determined later through evidence presented at trial.

Some lawyers argued that overlapping claims should be heard together to avoid multiple court proceedings and protect the rights of other Indigenous Nations. Others cautioned that allowing too many parties to join could make already lengthy and expensive Aboriginal Title trials even more difficult to complete.

The Supreme Court’s decision could establish clearer legal tests for future Aboriginal Title cases across Canada, helping courts balance the rights of Indigenous Nations seeking to participate with the right of those already pursuing recognition of their Aboriginal Title.

How could the Supreme Court rule?

The Supreme Court has several possible paths forward, and its decision does not have to be the same for the Nisga’a Nation and TSKLH.

Uphold the lower-court decisions:
The Nisga’a Nation would remain excluded as a defendant, while TSKLH could participate as a defendant but could not pursue its own Aboriginal Title claim within Gitanyow’s lawsuit.

Allow the Nisga’a Nation to join:
The Court could find that its treaty rights justify participation as a defendant in Gitanyow’s Title case.

Allow TSKLH to pursue its own Title claim:
The Court could permit TSKLH to advance a separate Aboriginal Title claim against the Crown within Gitanyow’s existing proceedings.

Establish stricter requirements for participation:
The Court could clarify what evidence, legal standing and connection to the territory are needed before another Indigenous Nation can join an Aboriginal Title case.

It could apply those tests itself or send certain questions back to the lower courts for reconsideration. This could mean additional hearings and further delays before Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title case proceeds.

Adopt a more flexible approach:
The Court could establish rules allowing other Indigenous Nations to protect their rights through different levels of participation, without necessarily becoming full defendants.

The Court could also combine elements of these approaches, reaching different conclusions for the Nisga’a Nation and TSKLH.

If the Supreme Court sends an issue back to a lower court, it does not mean Gitanyow’s entire case must start over. A lower court could be asked to reconsider only a specific question, such as whether another party should be allowed to participate. However, this could mean additional hearings and further delays before Gitanyow’s Aboriginal Title trial can proceed.

Whatever the outcome, the Supreme Court is not deciding whether Gitanyow holds Aboriginal Title to the Lax’yip. Its decision will address who can participate in Gitanyow’s Title case and could establish important legal precedents affecting Aboriginal Title litigation across Canada.

When can we expect a decision?

The Supreme Court of Canada heard the appeals on December 8 and 9, 2025. Gitanyow’s legal team estimated it would take approximately 10 months for their decision, but nothing has been released.

A recent Globe and Mail article identified the overlapping Aboriginal Title appeals among several major Supreme Court decisions still pending. The article also noted that retired Justice Sheilah Martin, who participated in the hearings, can only participate in judgments released before the end of November 2026.

This raises the possibility of a decision before the end of November, although the Court has not announced a release date.

The SCC provides counsel with a week’s notice of when a judgment will be released.

Supreme Court Of Canada